Many home business owners make innocent mistakes when managing their online reviews. While these actions are often well-intentioned, they can lead to serious trouble: lost customer trust, bans from major review platforms, expensive fines, and even government investigations.
While getting caught might seem unlikely, authorities do monitor review practices. More likely, a business will be reported by competitors, unhappy customers, disgruntled former employees, or even jilted lovers.
The good news is that these mistakes are completely avoidable once you know what to watch for. This article breaks down the five most common review mistakes that could hurt your home business and shows you how to safely build a trustworthy online reputation.
1. Don’t Break Review Site Rules
About This Review Mistake:
Each review platform has specific rules about how your home business can request reviews. Many business owners simply don’t know they exist, and the rules sometimes change.
Why Home Businesses Do It:
Most home business owners never read the fine print. They see the ways that many other businesses request reviews, and assume it’s okay to do it the same way. But the rules can surprise you, they can differ from one platform to the next, and busy entrepreneurs running a business from home don’t have time to study every platform’s rulebook.
What Could Happen:
A review platform can suspend your business listing, hide or flag your reviews, or ban you entirely. Think of it like a speed limit. Not seeing the sign doesn’t get you out of the ticket, and not knowing the platform’s rules won’t get you out of trouble.
How To Avoid It:
Get familiar with the rules for each online review site where your home business has a presence. Here are some examples from popular review sites:
- Google’s Prohibited Content policy prohibits offering incentives for reviews, “review gating” (the practice of filtering out unhappy customers), and content posted with a conflict of interest.
- Yelp’s policy tells businesses not to ask for reviews at all, as they believe it leads to biased feedback.
- Facebook/Meta’s Review guidelines and Community Feedback Policy are clear that reviews must be based on real purchasing experiences, and not be incentivized in any way.
2. Never Create or Purchase Fake Reviews
About This Review Mistake:
Posting any online review that doesn’t come from a real customer. It includes paying a service for reviews, writing them yourself under a fake name, or having people you know or employ post them.
Why Home Businesses Do It:
The pressure to get reviews is intense, especially for a home business. It gets even tougher when you see competitors with dozens of five-star reviews that are clearly not real. It’s easy to think it’s safe to arrange for fake reviews, but it’s a dangerous shortcut.
What Could Happen:
This is one of the quickest ways to get into serious trouble. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) considers fake reviews a deceptive practice, and has the authority to treat each fake review as a separate offense, with potential civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation. The legal costs and time it takes can crush your business. On top of that, review sites actively hunt for and remove fake reviews and can even ban your business entirely. If customers find out, the damage to your business’s reputation can be severe and long-lasting.
How To Avoid It:
Stick to earning reviews the honest way, by doing great work. Focus on creating a simple process to ask every customer for feedback. A handful of genuine, heartfelt reviews is always more powerful and trustworthy to potential customers than hundreds of fake ones.
3. Avoid Review Gating and Filtering
About This Review Mistake:
This mistake happens when you try to control the reviews you get and that you show the public on your website. It takes two common forms: first, asking customers if they were happy and only asking these customers for a review, and second, hand-picking only your five-star reviews to feature on your website while hiding the rest.
Why Home Businesses Do It:
This feels like a smart business move. Why would you want to send an unhappy customer a link to your Google review page? It seems logical to filter feedback to protect your reputation. Many home business owners believe they are simply putting their best foot forward by only showing glowing testimonials.
What Could Happen:
Major online review platforms like Google explicitly forbid review gating and selectively soliciting reviews in their contribution policies. You should also be aware that the FTC considers these practices deceptive because they create a false impression of your business. If a platform discovers it or someone reports you, they can penalize your listing or remove reviews. Worse, it could lead to government investigations and fines for deceptive advertising.
How To Avoid It:
Always be transparent. Send review requests to all your customers, regardless of whether you think they had a good or bad experience. When you display reviews on your website, show a balanced mix, not just the perfect ones. A potential customer is more likely to trust a business with a 4.7-star rating and a variety of feedback than one with a flawless 5.0 rating that looks too good to be true.
4. Use Caution When Offering Rewards for Reviews
About This Review Mistake:
This mistake is offering rewards for reviews in a way that violates platform rules or federal guidelines. For instance, Google’s policy on fake engagement directly forbids offering money, products or discounts in exchange for reviews. For other platforms that may permit them, the error is offering rewards only for good reviews or failing to ensure the customer discloses the reward.
Why Home Businesses Do It:
It can be difficult to get a busy customer to take a moment to write a online review. Offering a small gift, a discount, or a contest entry often feels like a harmless way to thank them for their time and encourage them to post.
What Could Happen:
If the platforms discover or even suspect that you are breaking their rules, they can remove your reviews or penalize your profile. And if a reviewer does not disclose that there was some incentive offered for the review, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) treated it as deceptive advertising, and according to the FTC’s guidelines, your business is liable!
How To Avoid It:
It can feel frustrating to play by the rules when you see competitors openly offering gift cards or free coffees for reviews. But this is a dangerous gamble for a home business. A single complaint from an unhappy customer or jealous competitor can trigger a platform suspension or investigation that you don’t have the time or money to fight. Ultimately, you have to decide if a small, temporary boost in reviews is worth the very real risk of fines or losing your entire review profile.
For a sustainable business, building trust is always the better investment, which highlights the importance of consumer reviews that are earned, not bought.
5. Don’t Get Reviews from Employees, Friends, and Family
About This Review Mistake:
This mistake is asking people with a personal connection to your home business to write a online review. This includes your staff, business partners, friends, and family members, even if they have genuinely paid for and used your product or service.
Why Home Businesses Do It:
When you first start out, your biggest supporters are often the people you know. It feels natural to ask your sister who bought your product or your neighbor who hired you for a service to leave a review. It seems harmless because they are real customers who want to see your home business succeed.
What Could Happen:
This could be viewed as a conflict of interest that both review platforms and federal regulators take seriously.
-
Platform Penalties:
Platforms are built on the trust of impartial reviews. Google’s misrepresentation policy, for example, explicitly prohibits content based on a conflict of interest. Their systems can sometimes detect these relationships, or someone might report them.
-
FTC Violations:
The FTC’s rules state that if employees or relatives endorse a product, their relationship must be clearly disclosed. If that connection is not mentioned in the review, it is considered deceptive, and your business is held responsible.
-
Reputation Damage:
Even if a review stays up, others might spot the connection (“Hey, isn’t that your relative?”) and use it to question the credibility of all your reviews.
How To Avoid It:
The safest rule is to build your reputation using reviews from unaffiliated, arm’s-length customers only. If a friend or family member who is a genuine customer insists on helping, explain to them why it’s so important to fully disclose their relationship in the review. For example, “Full disclosure: the owner is my brother, but his company did a fantastic job.” However, be aware that even with this disclosure, the platform may still suspect that the review violates its conflict of interest policy.
Don’t Take Chances: Build Trust the Right Way
The common thread in all these review mistakes is the temptation to take a shortcut. Running a home business is tough, and the pressure for a flawless online reputation can make even the most honest owner consider bending the rules.
But building a five-star reputation isn’t about quick fixes. It is about earning trust through consistency, which means developing a system for creating great experiences and professionally managing all the feedback you receive. A steady stream of genuine reviews, even if they aren’t all perfect, is far more powerful than a sudden burst of questionable ones. The principles of good review management are universal, as you can see demonstrated in resources like this guide to Google review management.
Your online reputation is one of your most valuable assets. By avoiding these common mistakes and focusing on authenticity, you are not just getting reviews. You are building a business that lasts.
Article Author: Les C. Cseh is the author of Get More 5-Star Reviews, owner of Results Pathfinder and a certified Digital Marketing Specialist
Find a Home-Based Business to Start-Up >>> Hundreds of Business Listings.
